Jump to content

Are anime fancervice edit more honest than original show?


Misari

Recommended Posts

as a tittle say many harem (I speak about harem cause have a lot ecchi/bath scene/ fancervice but even normal show sometimes)  use a fancervice like a weapon to love Ru or Dxd are two example. the question is why they never show under part expeccialy in a show when breast are weapon for money?? for example isnt more honest this edit than original?

 

[SPOILER] https://chan.sankakucomplex.com/post/show/4479066 [/SPOILER] original 

[SPOILER] https://chan.sankakucomplex.com/post/show/5918237 /SPOILER] edited

 

ps hope this don't hurt anyone
pps i know they censored for kids but many of these go/went ongoing during the night for this i ask

 

Edited by Optic
Added NSFW warning
Link to comment
Share on other sites

If I remember, Japanese law prohibits public distribution of "obscene" material. This is normally interpreted as meaning you cannot directly show genitalia; it has to be obscured or censored. 

In other words,  showing the lower part in something publicly sold, like anime, is basically illegal.

 

 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

19 minutes ago, SanguineTear said:

If I remember, Japanese law prohibits public distribution of "obscene" material. This is normally interpreted as meaning you cannot directly show genitalia; it has to be obscured or censored. 

In other words,  showing the lower part in something publicly sold, like anime, is basically illegal.

 

 

I think it is actually interpreted as not distributing male genitalia. Female parts are considered art. Go figure....

  • Agree 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

34 minutes ago, SanguineTear said:

If I remember, Japanese law prohibits public distribution of "obscene" material. This is normally interpreted as meaning you cannot directly show genitalia; it has to be obscured or censored. 

In other words,  showing the lower part in something publicly sold, like anime, is basically illegal.

that's have sense I don't know japanise law, but i think if xebec (in this case) made pic edited,  anime sold more= more money 

japanese are dumb can't show lower genitalia but in every anime have a tits at wind or sexually suggestive

 

Edited by Misari
  • Agree 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

34 minutes ago, Beocat said:

I think it is actually interpreted as not distributing male genitalia. Female parts are considered art. Go figure....

Hmm interesting. I would  personally think it applies to both but I'm no expert on Japanese law lol so you may be right. 

 

@MisariWell breasts aren't genitalia so they aren't considered as vulgar I guess. Either way, Japan as a whole is far more concerned about upholding what it considers standards for decency, they aren't concerned about hurting anime and manga sales. 

I agee though, I think it's stupid too. I personally hate all forms of censorship in media. 

Edited by SanguineTear
Link to comment
Share on other sites

personally i think only shota/loli (doesen't matter age)  must be afflicted by that law, cause they are child or they look like children even if they age is 99999999999 year old, these words may sound hypocritical but they are always children even if virtual  and even if  they are only  apparently children.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Those scenes to me would be extraordinary fan-service in mainstream titles (though not a mainstream genre of course). I don't feel it is censorship as a whole, as there are many explicit titles out there that are uncensored (which don't leave much to the imagination). 🙃

If it's too explicit (to the point of being pornographic) then you can't even broadcast it on TV. It would go straight to DVD/BD ..

Link to comment
Share on other sites

is not that point this is from BD from movie 2 fairy tail they show Erza full naked although it is only for 2 frames, with blank boobs and this is no sense, but i can understand (but not accept) the  censorship on ft) this was an anime went aired every saturday at 10:30 am, why do the animators use the censorship on an anime that was aired at 10:30 as one on air at 1:30 am? If a content is not for kids dosent matter if bd or tv size they musnt' not watch.

[SPOILER] https://giant.gfycat.com/CoarseHonoredBarnswallow.webm [/SPOILER]

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I (still) haven't seen Fairy Tail at all so I don't know that scene or character. But that to me looks like she's using an ability or transforming?

When compared to other anime titles I personally think that's fine and seems to be the norm - it reminds me of Kill la Kill where their outfits would literally dissolve into shining light and silhouettes during transformation scenes. Similar to magical girl titles - yes they become naked when they transform and show some skin but it's mostly a silhouette right?

Look at it this way, it could be so much worse... such scenes could be deleted altogether. Some of the US adaptations do that...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Optic changed the title to Are anime fancervice edit more honest than original show?
1 hour ago, Optic said:

I (still) haven't seen Fairy Tail at all so I don't know that scene or character. But that to me looks like she's using an ability or transforming?

When compared to other anime titles I personally think that's fine and seems to be the norm - it reminds me of Kill la Kill where their outfits would literally dissolve into shining light and silhouettes during transformation scenes. Similar to magical girl titles - yes they become naked when they transform and show some skin but it's mostly a silhouette right?

Look at it this way, it could be so much worse... such scenes could be deleted altogether. Some of the US adaptations do that...

yeah she use her magic for change her clothes/ or amor when she is fight, on the episode she never show herself naked (like movie)  but censored like this from ova 1,however

i cons, fairy tail   only if you  you like "nakama power" (friend power) and strong fancervice grey/ stripp off his clothes without reason and lucy go went battle in bikini for... i already speak about fancervice ?

[SPOILER] https://zippy.gfycat.com/GreenTanAltiplanochinchillamouse.webm [/SPOILER]

but i was thinking about another question maybe  in the prev reply i  probably explain badly.. why high school dxd hero (for example) is now aired at 00:30 pm is censored like fairy tail  went on air 10:30 am this This brings me to the topic title and the first links

Edited by Misari
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...