Interesting topic? Thanks, I like to question the 'weird'/'seemingly untalked' aspects of fandom from different and sometimes 'controversial' perspectives. I enjoy psychology, and how we respond to these creations!
A fellow HDN fan here I see. Glad to meet you aha! The characters also feel pretty realistic in a sense even though they are playing on tropes to me at least. Their personalities do seem to change but it still retains their core nature. In other words, I've noticed that they are the same individual, but whatever restrictions they may have had in their normal forms are liberated in their HDD ones. Good examples are: Plutia who changes into Iris who plays with the dominatrix persona (she's not really into it as evidenced by a quote between Mega and Iris in SeHA), where she feels liberated in expressing her intelligence + add some fun sadistic trolling lol. Then you have Uzume, who has to play a persona of 'cool' in the post-apocalyptic context to retain order, but then goes her true self as Orange Heart. Yes, at face value both Plutia/Iris Uzume/Orange could be seen as different beings unless they were more explored. It was a nice meshing of seemingly contrasting personalities as you've said. The warships one? I have not heard of it, I should look into it...
(oh boy, I don't mean to come off 'creepy obsessed' but let's just say I've delved into the personas of Plutia and some other characters purely based off me finally finding characters I can relate to very deeply!)
What I was getting more at was if you felt a portrayal of a character didn't really suit their core nature (regardless of contrasting forms), would you feel comfortable "modifying" them in a way you see fit and more true to their personalities?
And here's another mind twist: let's say if a character wasn't intended for a particular demographic, but you felt it would work there. Would you feel comfotable 'breaking the rules' to enjoy it because you feel it suits that character's personality more over what it was originally intended for?
You don't need to answer those if you find it weird. I know these are probably 'wth?'. But it's pretty entertaining to discuss such things sometimes.
What's this HDN forum theme?