cjjohns8

That's totally it! Thanks. Can't believe you found it with such vague info.

I don't remember. I think it came out in 2006 or 2007.

I'm trying to find the very first anime that I ever watched, which was about 11 years ago. Need some help as it was a fringe episode that only lasted one season and got overlooked by most people. -It had three main characters, one male protagonist and two female characters. The male protagonist was romantically interested in one of the girls, but both of the girls were interested in him, seemingly. -One of the female characters turned out to be his sister, kind of. The male protagonist turns out to be a clone or puppet of her brother who had died many, many years ago. She created him because she could not stand to be apart from him. He dies or stops existing at the end of series because he feels that his sister cannot move on as long as he exists. This was the only twist that makes it stand out from other anime. -The sister may have been a witch. She is super old. -It had a school vibe to it, and I believe remember them meeting on the roof of the school often.