I'd love to see how everyone determines how to rate an anime. Do you simply go off of the 1-10 on MAL or do you have your own standards?
For reference, here is the MAL rating scale...
1- Appalling
2- Horrible
3- Very bad
4- Bad
5- Average
6- Fine
7- Good
8- Very Good
9- Great
10- Masterpiece
and here is my personal rating scale...
10- I would suggest this to every anime lover or newbie and probably won’t ever stop talking about it. Highly recommended.
9- Everyone interested in this genre should watch this show. Excellent characters, plot, and production. Highly recommended.
8- This had good characters and plot, but some parts could be improved. Recommended.
7- This had decent characters or plot, but lacked quality in development and execution. Recommended for mindless entertainment.
6- If you’re bored with extra time with no other show to watch, you could maybe watch this.
5- This had one potentially good part or character, but overall pretty awful. Would not recommend.
4- I only finished it because I wanted to know what happened in the end; don't watch this.
3- I managed to get through the story, but it was a waste of my time.
2- I watched the a few episodes and deeply regretted it.
1- I couldn’t even make it through the first episode.
I posted, but then thought of this, so here's my list again!
https://myanimelist.net/animelist/ohnoitsanotaku