Ghost In The Shell Live Action: Thoughts?

Discussion in 'Title Discussion' started by ~EdgySenpai_Kyaaaa~, Apr 16, 2017.

  1. ~EdgySenpai_Kyaaaa~

    Feb 2, 2017
    7
    Female
    Professional meme-er, part-time sleeper and eater
    Planet Edgy... ~Kyaaa
    Ratings:
    +0 / 0
    Credits:
    480
    So recently I watched the Ghost In The Shell Live Action and was disappointed, to say the least. I was just curious to hear everyone else's thoughts on it.
     
  2. LolitaLegionnaire

    Apr 8, 2017
    12
    Male
    Ratings:
    +7 / 0
    Credits:
    780
    I already knew the movie was going to suck by seeing the trailers for it. Live action films for anime are always awful.
     
  3. MotokoKusanagi

    Apr 18, 2017
    2
    Male
    Ratings:
    +0 / 0
    Credits:
    230
    I hate her voice. She sounds nothing like the Major from the Anime, subbed or dubbed. Listening to her talk to herself is unbearable.
     
  4. Nutty

    Nutty Regular AF Member

    Mar 30, 2017
    62
    Male
    Student, Writer
    Ratings:
    +86 / 0
    Credits:
    9,510
    I can understand how you feel. Although, please keep in mind that you are comparing an anime to a live-action film - even though they are a part of the same franchise. There are certain things that animation can achieve, that live- action cannot. The same goes both ways. On top of that, they are two completely different mediums, in which people go to expecting different things.

    I think we as anime fans have all these preconceived notions on what an anime adaptation should be. Down to things like atmosphere, pacing and plot. We are expecting a live-action movie to give us the exact same things we got out of an animation, which is honestly quite unrealistic. Some, if not a lot of anime only work because of the medium it is present in. Shows are crafted to suit the way they will be portrayed in - the same definitely goes for anime.

    In short, we shouldn't expect a live-action movie to be an anime. And the producers shouldn't try to make one either. Instead they should strive to create the best possible movie they can, with the materials they have, in the medium which isn't animation.

    So I think it is unreasonable to desire a live-action movie to follow an animation to a tee. Besides, you can't have possibly wanted Maaya Sakamoto to do the voice acting, let alone act, for this movie.

    Personally, regarding the movie - I quite liked it. Although it didn't capture the full essence of the original, I think it was a neat attempt. Anime fans are just bashing it too hard.
     
  5. MotokoKusanagi

    Apr 18, 2017
    2
    Male
    Ratings:
    +0 / 0
    Credits:
    230
    It doesn't need to follow it 100% to be good, and she doesn't need to sound exactly as the anime. But I dislike her voice as Motoko. The Major is an already established character, anime or not; they aren't creating her from scratch. And so yes, having my experience of the Major already been created by the already established character, any subsequent version of the major is going to be contrasted against these experiences and said character. Fair or not, I would have preferred someone with a better voice to fit the part better.
     
  6. Sidney B. Gone

    Sidney B. Gone Bucket List Rejector

    Jul 22, 2016
    143
    Male
    Digital Artist, Poet and Asian Viking
    Australia/Oceania
    Ratings:
    +95 / 0
    Credits:
    2,800
    As much as I love ghost in the shell in any form of medium. This was a fun film all the same. Who cares if the type cast wasn't to point. It still was a neat and rather convincing interpretation of a classic. I for one love Scarlet Jo as the Major and Danish American as she is. That's a winning combination for any character, Motoko or otherwise. She is beautiful and a great actress. This will do not as good as I would have hoped, purely on the hate it is getting from jaded fans... sighs.
     
  7. The Bunk

    The Bunk Member

    Apr 3, 2017
    88
    Male
    Ratings:
    +49 / 2
    Credits:
    4,670
    #7 The Bunk, Apr 28, 2017
    Last edited: Apr 28, 2017
    What I said about it in another thread:

    Hmm, at the very most I'll bump it to a 7/10.
     
  8. TheAnimeTimes

    TheAnimeTimes The Ultimate Anituber

    May 1, 2017
    67
    Male
    Financial Analyst/Youtuber
    Ratings:
    +44 / 0
    Credits:
    2,330
    Basically this. Nothing wrong with the film itself, at all. I think it wasn't as good as the anime film, nor as deep, but by holding it to the same standards we miss out on a good hollywood action flick that, to be fair, is deeper than basically any other HOLLYWOOD movie out right now lol
     
  9. zoop

    zoop Forever hurtling toward the Earth.
    Moderator

    Jan 20, 2017
    840
    Female
    Washington
    Ratings:
    +2,478 / 9
    Credits:
    24,520
    Hm... gotta disagree with you on this one - I found the live action Rurouni Kenshin movies to be a total blast to watch. :-/
     
  10. TheAnimeTimes

    TheAnimeTimes The Ultimate Anituber

    May 1, 2017
    67
    Male
    Financial Analyst/Youtuber
    Ratings:
    +44 / 0
    Credits:
    2,330
    Kenshin live action? Was it basically just a more plot driven samurai flick?
     
  11. zoop

    zoop Forever hurtling toward the Earth.
    Moderator

    Jan 20, 2017
    840
    Female
    Washington
    Ratings:
    +2,478 / 9
    Credits:
    24,520
    The first movie was an adaptation of the series' opening, and features Udō Jin-e and Takeda Kanryū as villains. It's a bit condensed and features a decent number of changes to certain events and how a lot of the characters are introduced, but it works extremely well in my opinion, and made for a very nice and very stylized movie that wraps up quite nicely. Likewise with the second and third movies, which adapted the Kyoto arc.
     
  12. TheAnimeTimes

    TheAnimeTimes The Ultimate Anituber

    May 1, 2017
    67
    Male
    Financial Analyst/Youtuber
    Ratings:
    +44 / 0
    Credits:
    2,330
    Got it... I'll have to check it out then!
     
    • Agree Agree x 1
  13. zoop

    zoop Forever hurtling toward the Earth.
    Moderator

    Jan 20, 2017
    840
    Female
    Washington
    Ratings:
    +2,478 / 9
    Credits:
    24,520
    Disclaimer: While I absolutely adored the movies, I wasn't really a fan of the anime and thus went into the movies without any preconceptions about how things should be. If you're a big fan of the anime, some of the changes made might bother you.

    With that said, I think it was a solid adaptation overall and a very fun and approachable seriess of movies - I've introduced some folks to it who don't really like anime at all, and they found it to be a blast.

    So... yeah, just an FYI... with that said though, I still definitely recommend giving it a look.
     
  14. Frost

    Frost ·n i g h t l i g h t·

    Jul 9, 2016
    778
    Guardian
    United States
    Ratings:
    +2,359 / 11
    Credits:
    12,770
    I still have yet to watch this movie. :/ I've been scared to watch it. I'm the type of person who gets my hopes up with things. It was like when there was a live action Blood+ movie. I had higher expectations that the film could not fulfill. That being said, I absolutely love the idea of them making the live action movie, as it brought Ghost in the Shell back into the light for a lot of older fans. I will admit that the trailers weren't too eye catching for me. I don't have too much of an issue with the casting as other people do, but then again I haven't watched it yet, so I don't know how well they will portray the characters or not. Regardless, live action movies are always going to be a bit different than the original series, so I have no issue with giving it a fair shot, I just have yet to watch it. I will have to come back to this once I do.
     
  15. KimmyKins83

    KimmyKins83 Member

    Feb 11, 2016
    564
    Ratings:
    +161 / 2
    Credits:
    5,620
    I personally thought it was pretty good, so much so that I saw it at the cinema 3 times :) I think that as a whole when it came out it done much better in other countries such as over here in the UK where I live than what it did in the USA :) I'm now looking forward to getting it on Blu-ray :)
     
    • Like Like x 1
  16. Wodahs

    Wodahs Member

    Nov 18, 2016
    797
    Male
    defective
    limbo
    Ratings:
    +650 / 2
    Credits:
    35,600
    I'm still to get round to seeing this one
     
  17. CheesyTrees

    CheesyTrees Member

    Aug 21, 2017
    5
    Female
    Ratings:
    +2 / 0
    Credits:
    130
    I just saw it a few days ago. I'm not familiar with the original manga/anime, so I don't have anything to compare it off of, but it was better than I expected. Most of my expectations were colored by other people's disappointed opinions though, so I'm not sure how much that says ^^ It sounds like it may not have been as deep as the original, but like TAT said higher up, I found it more interesting and thought-provoking than a standard modern Western action film.

    I thought the casting was fine, though Scarlett's voice bothered me a little too with how flat it was. I'm curious what the original creators thought about the whole racial controversy thing ... on the one hand, you want to honor that the original comes from Japan, and on the other hand, my limited anime experience also seems to indicate that the entertainment industry isn't as pressured about representation as American entertainment is. It WAS a little odd seeing non-Japanese actors with such Japanese names, but I mean, we've all seen plenty of anime characters that are the same way also. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ I'm sure a Japanese cast would've done just as well or better, but I guess it depends on who wants those moneez.
     
  18. Florida Fool

    Florida Fool Member

    Jun 14, 2017
    50
    Male
    Real Estate Agent
    Florida
    Ratings:
    +20 / 0
    Credits:
    4,330
    Thought it was fine, even with the overblown complaints about being faithful to the anime in terms of race. However, I think casting all Japanese actors would've made more sense. Certainly, makes more sense than the casting for the FMA film. Though it makes me laugh when the same people who complain about being faithful to the original material are cheering the casting of Valkyrie, Domino, Johnny Storm, Heimdall and Jimmy Olsen.
     
Loading...
If you want to discuss something in more detail, please use the Forums to keep them alive, thanks!
  1. There are currently no users chatting.

Please login with your AF account to use the chat.

There are currently no users chatting.
Chat [0]