THE MOVIE
After the success of the first Creepshow, George Romero created the TV series Tales from the Darkside in 1983, which bears a similar focus on macabre stories as Tales from the Crypt. Shortly after the release of Creepshow 2, a movie based on the series was released in 1990. Rumored to be the real Creepshow 3 Romero had intended to create, Tales from the Darkside features three horror stories with a wraparound story like Creepshow 2.
Despite the disappointment of Creepshow 2, I found myself yearning for more twisted stories. I just can't get enough of them! The child in me had returned upon my rewatch of the first Creepshow two days ago and craves for more of such horrifying tales. Thankfully, rather than convincing me that the "Tales" brand of dark comedy is dead, this film actually brought back life to the genre! It's actually much better than Creepshow 2! Rumor or not, this works very well as a spiritual sequel to the Creepshow series.
The format of the movie begins (and ends) with a Hansel and Gretel sort of tale, where a paperboy is kidnapped by a modern day witch planning a dinner party. What a fantastic twist on the classic fairy tale! A dinner party! I could certainly imagine that for a modern day witch. I was liking the movie already.
Then we start our first story, Lot 249. This was based on an Arthur Conan Doyle story of the same name. Being a fan of Doyle and his most famous creation, the legendary detective himself, I was looking forward to this story and it didn't really disappoint. A graduate student is cheated out of his scholarship by his two classmates. Around the same time, he brought a mysterious large crate into his home, one that's marked with "Lot 249". This segment surprised me with how gruesome the movie went. Like the first two Creepshow, the effects look great enough for the gore to disturb me. The way the victims were killed were done very creatively (and brutally too) that it made for an interesting opening, very much unlike Creepshow 2's first segment.
After that, we have the best story of all written by Stephen the King himself, Cat from Hell. This was supposed to appear in Creepshow 2 but got cut out due to budgetary reasons. It's about a hitman hired by a wealthy but aging pharmaceutical tycoon to kill, of all things, a black cat. The story goes that the cat is supposedly a killer who has taken the lives of three people. Out of the three segments, this was probably the most gruesome of all, surprisingly enough considering that it's about a terror-cat. It's quite a straightforward tale where the hitman hunts down the cat through the mansion.
While I like this story, especially its minimalist approach, there was something that bugged me: the hitman's incompetence. In the film, he's hailed as this impressive hitman with twenty kills. But when I actually saw how he operated, I just couldn't buy that impressive record of his. He's clumsy, noisy, and has a poor sense of choosing an appropriate weapon (a syringe, IMO, would be much more troublesome than a simple pocket knife). If this was a Hitman video game, he would trip the alarm on Expert difficulty, let alone Professional. That said, I like the twist of why the cat showed up. It's unnerving and exactly the kind of cosmic revenge you would expect from a movie like this.
Finally, we have Lover's Vow. Now this one troubled me the most because it's written by someone I didn't know, Michael McDowell. I wasn't sure if the segment was going to be any good. Thankfully, my doubts were put to rest by the end, as this turned out to be quite the tragic love story based on the Yuki-onna. A starving artist finds himself involved in a gruesome murder, one committed by a horrifying-looking gargoyle who forces him to make a single promise in exchange for his life: never tell a soul about the gargoyle's existence. You can see from a mile away where this is going, but the payoff is nevertheless satisfying. It makes for a solid conclusion to the movie, and it leaves me interested in checking out the television show if its quality is any similar to the movie.
I would recommend any horror fan to check this one out, more so than the Creepshow films. Like Creepshow, it does have a playful tone as well, but the three main stories here are much more serious and horrifying, so you should definitely check them out if you love to be disturbed like me.
★★★★